Skip to content
FRSign inBook a walkthrough
ExplainerSMS fundamentals

What Happens After an Occurrence Report: The Six Stages

A tug touches a fuselage panel during pushback. Nobody is hurt and the aircraft goes for inspection. What happens to that report over the next two weeks is the difference between a safety system and a filing cabinet. Here are the six stages, what each one produces, and where most operations stop.
Mounir OuafiFounder and CEO of eAvioraPublished 11 min read

01Stage 1: intake

The person who saw it is usually standing outside. Intake should ask only for what they hold: what happened, where, when, who was involved, whether anyone was hurt, and what state the aircraft is in. Everything else, the reference, the location, the taxonomy code, the risk band, is the system job.

The failure mode: asking the reporter to classify. A form that requires a ramp agent to pick an aviation taxonomy code produces fewer reports and worse ones. Reporting volume is the raw material of the whole system, and every field you add to intake costs you some of it.

02Stage 2: classification and risk band

Classification places the occurrence in a taxonomy so it can be compared with others. Risk banding places it on the matrix so it can be prioritised. Software can propose both; a safety professional owns both, and the acceptance belongs on the record.

The matrix should be fixed rather than tuned per assessment, because a band only carries meaning if the same severity and probability produce the same answer across fleets and across years. See the aviation risk matrix explained for how tolerability is derived, and hazard versus risk for the distinction this stage depends on.

03Stage 3: the barrier

This is the stage most operations never reach, and it is the one that turns a report into prevention. The occurrence is evidence about a hazard, and usually about one specific control that did not hold. A ramp vehicle collision hazard might carry eight named barriers; a tug contact tells you which of them was degraded at the moment it mattered.

Because barriers are shared between hazard models, degrading one moves every model that leans on it. That is the whole argument for keeping barriers as named objects rather than as prose inside a risk assessment document. See bow-tie without the spreadsheet.

04Stage 4: the indicator

One occurrence is an anecdote. The indicator is where it becomes a trend. Ground damage rate plotted on a control chart with limits will trip a statistical rule when the process shifts, which is a different and much earlier signal than a bar going up in a monthly pack.

The failure mode: indicators recalculated by hand each month and presented as coloured arrows. Nobody can act on an arrow, and by the time three months of arrows point the same way the drift has been running for a quarter. See control charts versus trend bars and leading versus lagging indicators.

05Stage 5: the corrective action

An action that closes on a checkbox proves that something was done, not that risk fell. Both EASA Part-ORO and FAA 14 CFR Part 5 expect effectiveness verification, and the practical rule that makes it real is that the owner of an action is never its verifier.

This is where old chains come back. An action closed unverified months ago is frequently the reason a barrier was still degraded when the next occurrence arrived. See the closure gate for the mechanism.

06Stage 6: the decision

Where the risk warrants it, a safety action group or safety review board takes a decision and records it: what was decided, who voted, what changes, and who is accountable for the residual risk. The vote and the signatures belong to the record rather than to a separate set of minutes.

The useful test of a governance layer is whether its agenda can be derived from the safety data. If it is assembled by hand the week before, the board reviews what was remembered rather than what escalated. For how these records wire together across the system, see connecting occurrence, CAPA, SPI and the risk profile.

Questions

A well run occurrence report moves through six stages. It is received and given a reference; it is classified and risk assessed against a matrix; the hazard and barriers it exercised are identified and rated; the indicators that track that risk are re-evaluated; a corrective action is raised where the risk requires one, and the report does not close until that action is proven effective; and where the risk is significant, a decision is taken and recorded by a safety action group or safety review board. In a disconnected system the report usually stops after stage one or two, which is why reporters conclude that filing reports changes nothing.

Mounir OuafiFounder and CEO of eAviora, the aviation safety intelligence platform.

Related reading

Follow one occurrence through all six stages, on your own data.

Book a walkthrough on your own operation, or keep reading in all the insights.